Backyard Barbecue Chicken

Barbecue chicken is one of my comfort meals. More importantly, it’s one of the few meals that I love that my kids like even more than I do. It’s a combination of a few techniques I’ve discussed before:
1. Barbecue Rub
2. Barbecue Sauce
3. Grill-Roast Chicken Pieces basic technique

Now, I know this isn’t REAL barbecue – it’s not “low and slow” enough to qualify.* Technically, it should be called grilled chicken with barbecue sauce. But oh, is it good…
*Which reminds me of one of my favorite barbecue quotes, from Alton Brown, which goes something like:

“To make a french chef’s head explode, tell him you’re going to barbecue some barbecue with barbecue sauce on your barbecue for a barbecue. Then stand back.”

Recipe: Backyard Barbecue Chicken


Ingredients:

  • 3-4 lbs bone in chicken pieces (about 1 cut up chicken) – breasts, wings, thighs, drumsticks, with breasts halved.
  • 2 tsp kosher salt
  • 2 tsp barbecue rub
  • 2 cups barbecue sauce

Directions: (See Grill Roast Chicken Pieces for an overview of the technique)
1. Salt and rub the chicken: Up to 24 hours before cooking, rub the salt and barbecue rub all over the chicken pieces. If more than an hour before cooking, refrigerate the pieces until ready to cook.

2. Preheat the grill: Set your grill up to cook at indirect/high, and preheat for 15 minutes if it’s a gas grill.





Cooking indirect – the lit burners are on the far right and left of the picture, and the chicken is over the unlit part of the grill

3. Cook the chicken: Once the grill is preheated, put the chicken over the “indirect” part, away from the flames, skin down.  (Try to put the thighs, drumsticks and wings closer to the fire than the breast pieces, of you can.)  Close the lid, and let the chicken cook for 20 minutes, then flip skin side up, and cook for another 10 minutes. (Or until the chicken registers 150*F in the thickest part of the chicken breast pieces, and 160*F in the thickest part of the thighs).

4. First layer of barbecue sauce: Brush the chicken all over with 1 cup of the barbecue sauce. Cook it for another 5-10 minutes; at that point, the chicken should be 160*F in the breast, and 170*F in the thighs and drumsticks – if not, let it continue to cook, indirect, until it gets to those temperatures.

5. Second layer of barbecue sauce: (Optional) Brush the chicken with the last cup of barbecue sauce, then move over the direct part of the fire (that is, directly over the flames) and cook for 2-3 minutes a side to crisp up the glaze. Pull the chicken off the grill to a platter the moment it’s done; crisp can become burnt in a heartbeat.
6. Serve: …with any extra barbecue sauce on the side.

Notes:
*Barbecue sauce will burn, because of all the sugar in it. If you put it on when you started, it would be charred by the time the chicken was cooked through. That’s why we only have it on for the last 15 minutes of cooking (or so).

*Burnt barbecue sauce is also why step 5 is optional – the line between crisp and burnt is a very fine one. Err on the side of caution with this step, or skip it, if you’re not into dramatics with your cooking. It adds an extra layer of flavor, but it’s not required to have good chicken.

*Salting ahead of time: Ideally, salting 24 hours ahead of time gives it time to dry brine the chicken, which will season the chicken more thoroughly. Even an hour ahead of time will help. If you don’t have the time then rub the chicken right before starting the grill; that’s what I do on weeknights when I’m in a hurry to get dinner on the table.

*If you prefer, you can brine the chicken instead of early salting. I describe the brine in the Grill-Roast Chicken Pieces basic technique, but I’m starting to prefer the results from early salting over a brine. The brine’s advantage is it really only needs an hour to work its magic on the chicken; the early salting is best if it can go overnight, or at least 6 hours.

*You really need a silicon basting brush for this recipe. I’ve had to throw out every natural bristled brush I’ve ever used with barbecue sauce because I could never get it clean again. My current favorites are from Oxo – they’ve added a little tongue with holes on the inside of the brush to help it carry the sauce, and spread it more evenly. Without that piece, the sauce slides right off the silicon bristles.

Inspired by:
Cook’s Country magazine
Steven Raichlen



2 Comments

  1. Scubasuz /

    Hello, I am excited to try some of your recipes. I have a question about the BBQ chicken. I only have 3 burners on my grill with the third being a rotisserie burner in the back of the grill. Can I turn that one on for indirect heat? Otherwise I would have to use one of the two main burners for cooking.

    thanks,

    Suzanne

  2. @Scubasuz:

    You can use the rotisserie burner as the “second” burner, but you might not need it.

    If your grill can hold a temperature of 350* to 400*F with one of your main burners lit, then you don’t need the rotisserie burner. If it’s cooler than that, try adding the rotisserie burner in.

    Good luck, and let me know how it goes.